Skip to content

Web Development and Aversive Disablism

01/05/2009

Blogging Against Disablism Day, May 1st 2009

Blogging Against Disablism Day, May 1st 2009

At A Pretty Simple Blog, James Coltham writes a great article as part of Blogging Against Disablism Day considering the origins of ‘disablism’ and reflecting on the ways disablism plays out through web developers’ actions when creating inaccessible content. I recommend reading his post in full, but to crudely paraphrase, he observes that ignorance is no excuse:

Many will argue that if they do not know about the issues, they can’t be guilty of being ‘disablist’.

Further more, when considering accessibility on the web:

I struggle to think of a valid reason why a web professional should not know about, and practise, web accessibility. Of course, accessibility isn’t binary, and there are many grey areas. But the fact that we still see many of the “school-boy” errors (missing descriptions for images, text that won’t resize, etc) means that there is a long way still to go to get anywhere near an acceptable global standard.
And like it or not, every single person who makes the choice not to spend the 20 seconds giving that image a suitable description, or thinks that aesthetics beats usability, or who assumes blind people wouldn’t be interested in their site anyway – these people are the embodiment of disablism, because they have relegated the needs of those users (for whatever reason) and, by that action, cast them as inferior.

The issues James raises are an important and, I think, highlights the subtle ways in which discrimination and exclusion are propagated online. I would call this Aversive Disablism.

Aversive Disablism is a process identified by Mark Deal. His paper ‘Aversive Disablism, subtle prejudice towards disabled people’  (Disability & Society, Vol 22, No. 1, January 2007)  observes that blatent forms of prejudice towards disabled people appear to be declining in the UK. However, subtle forms of prejudice remain and persistently damage progression towards an accessible and equitable society.

Aversive disablists recognize disablism is bad but do not recognize that they themselves are prejudiced. Likewise, aversive disablism, like aversive racism, is often unintentional.

Deal draws from many different discussions of aversive racism to create an understanding of what he terms aversive disablism. He attests:

Aversive racists, Gaertner and Dovidio argued, are not anti-black, but pro-white. Likewise, aversive disablists may not be anti-disabled, but rather pro-non-disabled.

Deal makes several key observations. Firstly that this in-group favouritism can be can be as damaging to disabled people as more overt prejudiced behaviours. Secondly, it highlights how people who believe they hold a liberal attitude towards disabled people (including those with disabilities who do not identify as disabled) may support behaviour and social policy that excludes other disabled people.

When we transfer these ideas to specific contexts, Deal attests:

This is not to argue that the building industry is inherently disablist, but, as Young (1990) noted, ‘The conscious actions of many individuals daily contribute to maintaining and reproducing oppression, but those people are usually simply doing their jobs or living their lives and do not understand themselves as agents of oppression’.

In his blog post, I think James is observing the damaging actions of aversive disablist web developers.  When commissioning or building websites it’s vital that we recognise this subtle prejudice.

7 Comments leave one →
  1. 05/05/2009 9:43 am

    Hi Sarah, I’m proud to have been the inspiration for this post.

    I hadn’t heard of ‘Aversive Disablism’ before reading this but it absolutely sums up what I was talking about in my post. It’s a worrying issue and one we all need to be conscious of.

  2. 06/05/2009 2:11 pm

    I’m sorry it took me so long to get around to this, but this was an excellent post. I had not come across the idea of “aversive” prejudice before and think it is a very useful way of describing this problem. Thanks for contributing to Blogging Against Disablism Day!

  3. slewth permalink
    17/05/2009 3:31 pm

    Thanks James and Goldfish for the positive feedback – it’s great to hear. And special thanks to you Goldfish for the whole day – I know you must have put a ton of work into BADD and it’s been a fantastic event.

    I’ve been looking into aversive disablism and its relations to internet development. I’ve not found anything specific, so am hoping to get some more permanent thoughts published to kick start some discussion. I’ll keep you in the loop as and when this emerges.

Trackbacks

  1. Winner of John M Slatin Award at W4A 2010 « UK Web Focus
  2. You Have 5 Seconds to Make an Impression! « UK Web Focus
  3. #1 ‘Aversive disablism: subtle prejudice toward disabled people’ by Mark Deal « 32 Days Remaining
  4. Aversive Disablism, Web Accessibility and the Web Developer « UK Web Focus

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: